On the day when Israel bombed the surgical wards and intensive care units of Nasser Hospital in Gaza, killing at least 6 including the surgeon and wounding many more, Andy Burnham rejected Jeremy Corbyn’s call for an inquiry into the complicity of the UK in the ongoing genocide.
This is despite a call by the United Nations, as long ago as 2024, saying “all arms exports to Israel must stop immediately, as to continue would be likely to violate international humanitarian law.”
This is also despite Andy Burnham seeking to distinguish himself from Keir Starmer by saying at the 2026 Labour Party Conference to resounding applause that “Labour got it wrong on Gaza”. Starmer’s government had been forced into suspending 30 arms exports to Israel in September 2025 but continued to send components for the F25 fighter jets. It was hoped by many that Burnham’s statement was drawing a line in the sand. His government would have the courage to stand up to the USA and Israel, recognise the actions of the far right Israeli government as genocidal and stop all arms shipments. He made the right noises by announcing sanctions on illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, but he then said no more. He has refused to describe the actions of the Israeli government as genocidal, stating that “determining whether genocide has occurred is is a matter for international courts and legal bodies rather than politicians”. He has continued to allow the sale of military equipment to Israel, and military flights to Israel from UK bases have continued.
One can only wonder whether he has had time to read the landmark reports submitted to the UN General Assembly in September 2025 and October 2026. This three member panel concludes that Israel has committed and continues to commit genocide against the Palestinian people, citing mass killings, starvation, destruction of healthcare and the education systems. They also cite statements by Israeli officials demonstrating genocidal intent. He may also have overlooked a report earlier this year by a UN commission that Israel is committing genocide by deliberately targeting children. And he may have missed statements by a raft of human rights and humanitarian organisations, including Israeli human rights groups, legal and genocide prevention groups, international courts, along with genocide scholars. He is clearly grasping at the straw that the ICJ will not finish its formal deliberations until 2029. The ICJ has though stated that the Palestinians have “a plausible right to be protected from genocide”, and have issued binding provisional orders requiring Israel to prevent genocidal acts and allow humanitarian aid into Gaza. There is a silence and complicity over the fact that these Orders are being broken daily. There is certainly no ceasefire. Now, instead of bombing homes, hospitals and schools they are bombing tents. Over 1610 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since the start of the so-called ceasefire. At the same time Israel enforces strict border controls over goods that enter Gaza, including shelter and winterisation materials, water pumps, medical equipment such as x ray machines and oxygen tanks. They even stop every day supplies like paper and pencils for schools, sleeping bags, torches and portable toilets. Anything, in fact that makes life without shelter or safety bearable.
He may also have been advised that there are reasons to preserve the strategic relationship with Israel, but any question of unconditional support are being questioned by many, including former diplomats, who say that it is now too heavily compromised by legal and humanitarian issues over Israeli’s behaviour in Palestine. At the same time repeated polls show only a small minority of British people now support Israel’s actions in Palestine.
A YouGov poll commissioned by Medical Aid for Palestine in April 2026 found that just 13% of those polled are in support of Israel’s ongoing military actions in Gaza. 54% support the UK government ending all arms exports to Israel, including parts for F-35 jets compared to just 22% in opposition.
We can only guess why Andy Burnham, who has based his career on courting popularity, is so willing to go against public opinion over Palestine. Perhaps he is refusing a public inquiry because he knows that it will confirm the Labour Government’s complicity and culpability in Israel’s genocidal policy.
It could also be that he is treading that fine line with his MPs, knowing that approximately 39% of his top cabinet team are affiliated with or supporters of Labour Friends of Israel, according to the National published in July 2026. The fate of Jeremy Corbyn, who refused to follow the party line on Israel must be etched on his memory, although appointing a former Chair of LFI, James Purnell as his Chief of Staff hints at more than a pragmatic approach to managing powerful interest groups.
Janen Ganesh in the Financial Times on the 11 November disagrees. In his article The Wonderful Shallowness of Andy Burnham (behind a pay wall) he suggests that his political appeal lies in saying what people want to hear without doing very much. He is described as a tonal socialist – a politician who uses left wing language while pursuing moderate policies. The problem is that on Gaza he is doing neither.
Of course, agreeing to Jeremy Corbyn’s request for a Chilcot type Inquiry, speaking out about the genocide, and even doing the minimum of stopping arms sales to Israel and preventing our bases being used for surveillance flights, will not stop Israel’s murderous intentions and relieve the suffering of the Palestinian people. It will, though, show leadership and demonstrate that Britain is finally prepared to put international law and human rights before political expediency.
Perhaps Janan Ganesh is right that Burnham understands the political value of saying what people want to hear without committing himself to substantial change. But there is a profound difference between political caution and moral failure. When a government has the power to act against atrocities and chooses instead to look away, silence is not neutrality. It is a political choice, and one for which history will judge him.
Discover more from Penumbrage
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
