When the BBC Today programme reported on the landmark International Court of Justice decision that the Myanmar government had committed genocide against its minority Muslim population, the Rohingya, in 2017 there was no mention of its continuing investigation of Israel. This is remarkable when you think that this was the first time a national government has ever been found guilty of genocide and the only other country in the frame for genocide at present is Israel.
By lunchtime the World at One did report that there might be implications for Israel in the judgement but that was it. There was no examination of the parallels between the two cases, and definitely no discussion of the UK government’s complicity with both Myanmar and Israel.
Myanmar
Declassified UK has just published an updated version of an article first published in 2021 which details how the Conservative government of the day provided material support to the Myanmar regime throughout the genocide even though it was aware of what was happening. The headline news was that:
- UK military training of Myanmar troops was only stopped near end of Rohingya genocide
- A British army colonel remained at UK embassy in Myanmar during genocide as “point of contact…for any military issues that the Burmese might have”
- Foreign Office continued to promote trade with Myanmar during genocide
Israel
This time round a UK airbase in Cyprus has been used to transport arms to Israel. UK has flown drones over Gaza to provide intelligence to Israel. It has provided diplomatic support at the UN. Arms sales to Israel have increased during the genocide and there has been no interruption of trade. At home the Labour government has tried to criminalise support for Palestine and declared Palestine Action a terrorist organisation.
If anything the evidence against Israel is even more damning than in the case of Myanmar. The reason the case against Myanmar has taken nine years and was only reached on a majority decision is because it is not enough to decide that genocidal events took place. You also have to prove intent to commit genocide. We have seen the genocidal events in Gaza and the West Bank that target the entire civilian population: denying food, water, shelter and medical aid; killing tens of thousands with indiscriminate bombing; destroying essential infrastructure and cultural heritage; targeting children and widespread sexual violence.
And so many Israeli spokespersons have declared their genocidal intent that the United Nations, the International Association of Genocide Scholars, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention, Genocide Watch, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Médecins Sans Frontières have all recognised that Israel is committing genocide.
Yet again a UK government, this time a Labour Government, comes out with the lame excuse that it cannot act until the courts decide that a genocide has happened.
They are lying to us!
All signatories to the Genocide Convention are obligated to act in order to prevent genocide. If someone sets fire to your neighbour’s house you don’t watch it burn and wait for the courts to decide if it was arson. You help to put the fire out. If Israel is bombing and starving the population of Gaza you don’t wait ten years for the ICJ to decide. You stop selling arms to Israel. You stop spying for Israel. You impose economic sanctions on Israel. You join South Africa in their case against Israel at the ICJ.
Labour under Starmer openly declared their support for Israel. Labour under Burnham have said they got it wrong. But they are doing next to nothing to put it right. There may have been some sanctions on individuals involved in the theft of Palestinian land and ethnic cleansing in the Occupied Territories of the West Bank. Yet Burnham’s Labour government has no qualms about banning foreign academics sympathetic to Palestine because their presence “is not conducive to the public good.
The latest was Andreas Malm, a Swedish academic who campaigns over fossil fuels and Palestine. He was due to speak at an event organised by Tribune. They report that they then arranged for him to speak via a video link and the Home Office put pressure on Hackney Council to cancel the event. This tactic failed thanks to a principled stand by Hackney Mayor Zoë Garbett (Green Party) who overruled her officials and the packed meeting went ahead with Malm on video.
Labour Friends of Genocide
In other news The National Scot reports that Burnham’s Labour government has failed to sanction Shivat Zion, a company that actively supports the illegal settlements in the West Bank and is currently touring the UK raising funds and recruiting settlers. The government cannot plead ignorance. The National Scot quotes Dora Fidler, a spokesperson for Jewish Anti-Zionist Action:
Over the past year we have exposed Shivat Zion for promoting Israeli settlements, illegal under international law, in the UK to Jews looking to move to Israel. That the group is not already sanctioned after this is absurd, but that it is allowed to potentially continue this facilitation of war crimes across Britain on its ‘tour’ is deplorable.
It also quotes Nur Nabulsi, a spokesperson for the Palestinian Youth Movement:
The Burnham Government’s piecemeal approach to sanctions enables groups like Shivat Zion to sell to prospective settlers in Britain. Only comprehensive sanctions on Israel and settler organisations can hope to curb the violent displacement of Palestinians from their land. Labour does not want to take action against groups like Shivat Zion because doing so would expose how deeply interconnected settler organisations are with the Israeli ‘state’ itself.
It also does not want to expose how, just as in Myanmar, the British state is deeply interconnected with the Israeli state. This explains why Andy Burnham rejected Jeremy Corbyn’s call for an inquiry into the complicity of the UK in the ongoing genocide. Labour Friends of Genocide are in it up to their necks.
Discover more from Penumbrage
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
